Ratings Overview - Rain Boots

Total 10 products tested
Compare Gear Review Summary Retail Price Overall Rating Sort Icon Category Ratings
Compare
up to 5
Products sorted by Overall Rating score List Price Score 0-100 Water Resistance Comfort Traction Warmth Style Ease of Use
Bogs Classic Ultra High
The Bogs Classic Ultra High rain boot won our Editor's Choice award because it continually surprised us with its comfort and warmth, no matter whether we were standing on concrete floors for 10...  read more >
$135

Editors' Choice Award
100
0
72
Water Resistance - 5 of 10
5
Comfort - 9 of 10
9
Traction - 5 of 10
5
Warmth - 8 of 10
8
Style - 8 of 10
8
Ease of Use - 10 of 10
10
The Original Muck Boot Company Arctic Sport
The Original Muck Boot Company Arctic Sport is meant for those who need a boot for the worst weather. It's a heavy-duty, fleece-lined, neoprene wrapped, studded tank of a boot. If you make the...  read more >
$170

Top Pick Award
100
0
68
Water Resistance - 9 of 10
9
Comfort - 3 of 10
3
Traction - 9 of 10
9
Warmth - 10 of 10
10
Style - 6 of 10
6
Ease of Use - 5 of 10
5
Baffin Enduro
When we think of rain boots, we imagine a boot much like the Baffin Enduro: thick rubber, stiff but comfortable enough to walk in for hours, waterproof up to our calves, and ruggedly utilitarian...  read more >
$55

Best Buy Award
100
0
67
Water Resistance - 7 of 10
7
Comfort - 7 of 10
7
Traction - 8 of 10
8
Warmth - 4 of 10
4
Style - 5 of 10
5
Ease of Use - 6 of 10
6
Kamik Icebreaker
The Kamik Icebreaker isn't a run-of-the-mill rainboot, and with their work-wear good looks, optional lace closure system, removable felt insulating liner, great traction, and relatively high shaft...  read more >
$65

100
0
64
Water Resistance - 5 of 10
5
Comfort - 6 of 10
6
Traction - 8 of 10
8
Warmth - 7 of 10
7
Style - 7 of 10
7
Ease of Use - 8 of 10
8
The Original Muck Boot Company Edgewater II
The Original Muck Boot Company Edgewater II falls in the middle of the pack when it comes to most of our metrics - water resistance, comfort, and warmth - but this doesn't mean they're a bad boot...  read more >
$120

100
0
54
Water Resistance - 6 of 10
6
Comfort - 5 of 10
5
Traction - 3 of 10
3
Warmth - 6 of 10
6
Style - 4 of 10
4
Ease of Use - 8 of 10
8
XTRATUF Legacy Series 15"
XTRATUFs belong to Alaska, and we were excited to see how they'd do in Pacific Northwest conditions. We have several friends who regularly wear XTRATUFs - all from Alaska or with Alaskan relatives -...  read more >
$135

100
0
53
Water Resistance - 6 of 10
6
Comfort - 6 of 10
6
Traction - 6 of 10
6
Warmth - 2 of 10
2
Style - 7 of 10
7
Ease of Use - 2 of 10
2
Hunter Original Tall
Hunter boots have been around for over 150 years, and while their dedication to handcrafting their boots with natural rubber is impressive, we did not find that these boots performed better than...  read more >
$155

100
0
50
Water Resistance - 8 of 10
8
Comfort - 4 of 10
4
Traction - 4 of 10
4
Warmth - 3 of 10
3
Style - 4 of 10
4
Ease of Use - 3 of 10
3
Bogs Carson
If you don't want it to look like you're wearing rain boots, but still want to have dry feet around town, go for the Bogs Carson. They feature a slimmer cut that almost looks like a dress shoe (in...  read more >
$125

Top Pick Award
100
0
49
Water Resistance - 3 of 10
3
Comfort - 7 of 10
7
Traction - 5 of 10
5
Warmth - 5 of 10
5
Style - 9 of 10
9
Ease of Use - 2 of 10
2
LaCrosse Alpha Muddy
In our last rain boot review, the LaCrosse Hampton was a Top Pick for Mild Use, due to its casual looks and comfortable fit. We initially intended to test that boot again and to see how it measured...  read more >
$100

100
0
33
Water Resistance - 3 of 10
3
Comfort - 3 of 10
3
Traction - 4 of 10
4
Warmth - 6 of 10
6
Style - 2 of 10
2
Ease of Use - 2 of 10
2
RK Waterproof Rubber Sole
When we initially worked on narrowing 49 rain boots down to 10 pairs for testing, we wondered whether the more expensive boots were worth the extra money. These boots were $19, and the most popular...  read more >
$19

100
0
24
Water Resistance - 3 of 10
3
Comfort - 1 of 10
1
Traction - 4 of 10
4
Warmth - 1 of 10
1
Style - 4 of 10
4
Ease of Use - 3 of 10
3
Compare
up to 5
Products sorted by Overall Rating score List Price Score 0-100 Water Resistance Comfort Traction Warmth Style Ease of Use
Total 10 products tested