≪ Go to our review of Coolers
Hands-on Gear Review
Rubbermaid Extreme 5-Day 75qt Review
Cons: Poor insulation, lack of durability, difficult to drain
Bottom line: Not terrible, but there are certainly better wheeled models available
Capacity (quarts): 69
Weight: 16.6 lb
Wheels are a great addition to a cooler, but unfortunately the Rubbermaid Extreme 5-Day 75qt's wheel design doesn't add much functionality. The wheels are small enough that they don't reduce rolling resistance to a considerable degree. If you're looking for a wheeled model we would recommend spending a bit extra on the Coleman Xtreme 5 Wheeled 100qt or, if you have a bit extra room in the budget, getting the exceptional Igloo Glide PRO 110qt. If you just want an inexpensive model, we think the Coleman Xtreme 5-Day 70qt would serve you better. It doesn't have wheels, but isn't much harder to slide around than the Rubbermaid.
RELATED REVIEW: The Best Coolers and Ice Chests of 2018
Our Analysis and Hands-on Test Results
The Extreme was the worst performer in our insulation tests, earning a score of 2, and did not live up to it titular 5-day claim. It was able to maintain safe food storage temperatures for 2 full days and ran out of ice after 4 days. It should also be noted that it briefly reached temperatures above 40˚F in the middle of day 2, but for less than an hour, which is inside the time limit for safe food storage set by the FDA. This result makes the Rubbermaid the only model we tested that would not last through a long weekend camping trip. Considering this poor performance and the fact that it includes built-in wheels, the Extreme is better suited for rolling a bunch of cans to the end of the dock for sunset drinks rather than storing food on any extended adventures.
The Extreme displays the level of durability one might expect from a traditional cooler. Its hinges and handles are fairly flimsy and a number of user reviews can be found that mention them breaking during normal use. The drain plug leash broke during our testing, it was the only structural casualties we experienced first hand. While the drain plug still functioned properly, we had to remember where we put it after draining, something that shouldn't be required of a model with a drain plug leash. The lid on the Extreme was the most bendable one we tested, and the only one we had any real trepidation about using as a seat. The lid also leaked large amounts of water in our slosh test, indicating a lack of structural integrity. If you're looking for longevity you would be better served with a high-end model, all of which scored 7 or 8 in our durability testing.
Ease of Use
The internal latch design on the Extreme's lid is the least favorite amongst our testers and can be finicky to get open, especially when the cooler is empty. Once open the lid easily stays open. The dual opening lid design lets you check on contents without opening the entire lid, but probably contributes to the lid's flimsiness. The drain on the extreme is fairly easy to open and produces a splash-free stream of water. However, the addition of wheels forces the Extreme's drain to be very high up the body, meaning you must essentially tilt the cooler 90 degrees to get all the water to drain. This can be quite a pain, especially in our crowded testing room, or when trying to drain from within a car trunk. The Extreme avoided the bottom spot in our ease of use scoring, but still received a below average score of 6. The top score in this metric was an 8 and the bottom was a 5.
The Extreme's carrying handles are all hard plastic. They are similar to but longer than all plastic handles of the Max Cold, and much shorter and skinnier than the all plastic handles of the Pelican Elite Cooler 70. These handles made for a reasonably comfortable carry during our carry test. Our testers put it in the middle of the pack in terms of carry ability. Our testers were not particularly impressed with the Extreme's wheels, some remarking that the other smooth bottomed traditional models slid just as easily without the benefit of wheels. However, you definitely won't find us sliding any of those other models across a parking lot, so the Extreme's wheels do have an added value. Overall it scored a 6 in our portability testing. This puts it just about average in a field with scores ranging from 4 to 7.
The Extreme's standout feature is its wheels, and the associated long handle that facilitates their use. It also includes two cupholders built into the lid and a drain plug leash. We awarded the Extreme a score of 4 in our features test. In a metric with scores falling from 3 to 7, this puts the Extreme just below average.
The Extreme was outperformed in our tests by the other traditional model we tested. It lists for $20 more than the Best Buy winning Coleman Xtreme 5-Day. The wheeled Igloo Glide PRO 110qt is orders of magnitude better, and lists for only $10 more.
While still comparable, the Extreme received lower scores than the other traditional model we tested. Whether you just want an inexpensive model or specifically want wheels, there are better options out there.
— OutdoorGearLab Review Team
You Might Also Like
The Best Coolers and Ice Chests of 2018Looking to keep food cold on your next camping trip or beach day? We researched hundreds of coolers, then bought the...
OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews
Most recent review: February 8, 2018
Where's the Best Price?
*You help support OutdoorGearLab's product testing and reviews by purchasing from our retail partners.
Table of Contents