< Go to Trail Running Shoes - Men's

Hands-on Gear Review

ALTRA Superior 3.0 Review

Price:   $110 List | $109.90 at Amazon
Pros:  Zero drop, lightweight, wide toe box, improved sidewall durability
Cons:  Sizing and fit still a little off, adding rock plate insert affects fit
Bottom line:  A lightweight zero-drop shoe for the speedsters and minimalist runners out there.
Editors' Rating:     
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Manufacturer:   ALTRA

Our Verdict

The Altra Superior 3.0 has been updated to fix a couple of the most glaring problems from the previous version, and otherwise remains basically the same shoe as last year's 2.0. We love this shoe as the only zero drop (or 0mm heel-toe drop) shoe in the review. It truly does feel different to run without added cushioning underneath the heel, and we recommend that runners of all abilities and experiences give this a try sometime. These shoes are the more minimalist and lightweight offering from Altra, with the more traditional Altra Lone Peak 2.0 - Women's being featured in our women's review. For those interested in low-profile, very light, or zero drop, this is the shoe that we recommend.


RELATED REVIEW: The Best Men's Trail Running Shoes of 2017 - Side-by-Side Tests

select up to 5 products
Score Product Price Our Take
81
$130
Editors' Choice Award
Our favorite shoe, high performance for everyone.
80
$130
Top Pick Award
Tons of comfy cushioning at a super light weight.
80
$125
Top Pick Award
Running fast on difficult terrain has never been so easy as with these shoes.
80
$120
Best Buy Award
Great as an everyday trainer, for ultra distances, or as all-around do everything shoe.
79
$110
A lightweight zero-drop shoe for the speedsters and minimalist runners out there.
78
$120
Super aggressive traction make this shoe suitable for the gnarliest of conditions.
76
$120
Not a flashy shoe, but performs well. Great everyday trainer.
74
$110
A very lightweight option that is designed like a traditional shoe.
74
$125
The lightest weight shoes for uphill trail running that we could find.
73
$125
Succeeds in its mission to crush the Leadville Trail 100.
72
$120
Good balance between protection and sensitivity, really durable!
72
$130
A mountain and skyrunning monster.
66
$120
Our least favorite Cascadia we have tested, wouldn't recommend to a friend.
64
$115
A beast who's best attribute is the ability to protect your feet.

Our Analysis and Hands-on Test Results

Review by:
Andy Wellman
Senior Review Editor
OutdoorGearLab

Last Updated:
Thursday
September 8, 2016

Share:
The Superior 3.0 is essentially the same shoe that it was last year with a couple of notable improvements. The first thing that Altra did was reinforce the sidewalls of the upper with more durable ripstop fabric. Durability of this sidewall was a problem that we pointed out in last year's review, were we had seen many instances of complete blowout. In our testing this issue seemed to be fixed nicely. Altra also made the shoe about size bigger this year, as last year's model certainly ran small. While it does fit noticeably better, we still feel like it is slightly short for the size. This didn't bother us at all until we put in the removable Stoneguard inserts.

The best feature of this shoe is predictably its zero drop, which provides unparalleled stability, amazing trail feel, and supports a natural running gait. It is recommended for runners who typically run in a high heel-toe drop shoe to transition slowly to zero drop shoes, either by running in them on a few short runs per week at first or by slowly working downward in terms of drop in successive pairs of shoes. Zero drop shoes, while anatomically more natural, often create more stress on the Achilles tendon and calves of runners who are not adjusted to them, and in some cases can lead to injury if a runner doesn't take the time to adapt properly.

Performance Comparison


The San Juan Mountains are littered with exotic trails that are carved out of natural rock shelves like this one  invariably by miners hoping to reach their stash over 100 years ago. Here we enjoy the Perimeter Trail above Ouray in the Altra Superior 2.0 shoes.
The San Juan Mountains are littered with exotic trails that are carved out of natural rock shelves like this one, invariably by miners hoping to reach their stash over 100 years ago. Here we enjoy the Perimeter Trail above Ouray in the Altra Superior 2.0 shoes.

Foot Protection


The Superior 3.0 comes with the unique option of a removable rock plate insert that they call the Stoneguard. This is an insertable piece of plastic that one slides in underneath the insole. While it does add protection to the shoe, the insert is merely a thin piece of plastic, not really a dedicated rock plate like other shoes feature. We also felt like with the Stoneguard insert added in, the fit of the shoe changes, and it becomes less roomy, especially in the toe box. We greatly preferred these shoes without the Stoneguard, and others that we talked to who run in them all claimed to normally run without it, like we did. For this reason, we chose to rate the shoe, in all categories, as if the Stoneguard was not present in the shoe.

The Superior 2.0 does not have a rock plate built into the shoe  but rather provides a "rockshield" insert that you can add underneath the insole should you like. We loved the sensitivity and flexibility of this shoe without the insert  and didn't feel like having it in place really stiffened things up very much.
The Superior 2.0 does not have a rock plate built into the shoe, but rather provides a "rockshield" insert that you can add underneath the insole should you like. We loved the sensitivity and flexibility of this shoe without the insert, and didn't feel like having it in place really stiffened things up very much.

Without the Stoneguard, we thought this shoe was a bit light on the foot protection compared to the rest of the shoes reviewed, and so gave it 6 out of 10 points. While it is nicely cushioned, it is certainly possible to take a sharp rock to the sole that would be felt roughly by the foot. The upper is thin and does not have any protective overlays, and the toe bumper is flimsier than most. Protection was this shoe's least impressive aspect, but it still scored slightly higher than the La Sportiva Helios 2.0.

Traction


Compared to the competition, we felt that the traction on this shoe warranted a score of 7 out of 10, roughly the same as the New Balance Leadville V3 or the Mizuno Wave Hayate 2. The Trailclaw outsole has a good selection of directional lugs, but much fewer than what is quickly becoming the norm. There are a handful of cutouts in the outsole that allows for greater flexibility and sensitivity, and while not the stickiest, we would call it sticky enough for scrambling and rocky terrain.

The outsole of the new Superior 2.0 (left) remains essentially unchanged compared to last years version (right). Altra calls this the "Trail Claw"and for having relatively low profile lugs  we think the grip is good.
The outsole of the new Superior 2.0 (left) remains essentially unchanged compared to last years version (right). Altra calls this the "Trail Claw"and for having relatively low profile lugs, we think the grip is good.

Stability


Stability is the best quality of this shoe, as you would expect from a shoe with zero drop and a very low stack height to go along with it. Not only that, but the shoe is designed with a very wide forefoot so that the toes and metatarsals can splay out to their full width upon landing and push off, allowing for the most natural, and stable, running platform of any shoe that we tested. In fact, no other shoe felt as stable as this one, and so we awarded it the full 10 points.

A characteristic of the Altra line of shoes is the very wide forefoot and toe-box. This is designed to allow your foot to splay out naturally when you land on your forefoot  as you tend to while wearing zero drop shoes. Chippy likes the look.
A characteristic of the Altra line of shoes is the very wide forefoot and toe-box. This is designed to allow your foot to splay out naturally when you land on your forefoot, as you tend to while wearing zero drop shoes. Chippy likes the look.

Comfort


This was a very comfortable shoe that never-the-less had a couple very minor things that we could complain about, and forced us to give it only 8 points instead of 9 like many others. Besides running slightly short, the fit was a bit too full, and even a little crammed if we wore the Stoneguard rockshield, which we therefore opted not to do. Our other complaint was that the outsole and midsole seem to be rockered at the front of the shoe, which has the effect of forcing our toes upward into the upper when wearing it. It is the only shoe where the tops of our toes are often in contact with the upper. Overall, a comfortable shoe, much like the ASICS GEL-FujiTrabuco 4 Neutral or The North Face Ultra Endurance, but not the most comfortable one we tested.

Weight


Without the rock plate insert, these shoes weighed a very low 20.3 ounces for a pair of size 11's. This was not as light as the La Sportiva Helios 2.0, but good enough for second best, roughly the same as the HOKA ONE ONE Challenger ATR 2 and the Mizuno Wave Hayate 2. These shoes are very light, and that is one of the best things about them. Their light weight helps solidify the feel of running the natural way. For reference, with the Stoneguard inserted into the shoe they weigh 22.6 ounces, still very light.

Lightweight  low to the ground  and natural feeling with their zero drop from heel to toe  the Superior 2.0 shoes will really inspire you to fly along on the trails.
Lightweight, low to the ground, and natural feeling with their zero drop from heel to toe, the Superior 2.0 shoes will really inspire you to fly along on the trails.

Sensitivity


Without a ton of foot protection to dissociate oneself from the feel of the trail, these shoes are among the most sensitive we tested. They give great trail feel and allow for a light and nimble stride, while at the same time still providing enough cushioning so that they are not a liability. Only the Mizuno Wave Hayate 2 and the La Sportiva Helios 2.0 were more sensitive than these shoes.

Best Applications


The Superior 2.0 will excel in short trail running applications. Due to the lack of foot protection we can't recommend it for ultra type outings, although there will certainly be people who will love it for this length anyway. This is a shoe that will help you to run fast, but probably not the best choice for bombing long rocky descents.

Running near Cascade Falls on the Perimeter Trail around the town of Ouray  Colorado  in the Superior 2.0. Once some people switch to zero drop shoes  they never go back. We are quite so fanatical  but the feel is noticable and refreshing every time we put these shoes on.
Running near Cascade Falls on the Perimeter Trail around the town of Ouray, Colorado, in the Superior 2.0. Once some people switch to zero drop shoes, they never go back. We are quite so fanatical, but the feel is noticable and refreshing every time we put these shoes on.

Value


The Superior 2.0 still costs $110. A couple of years ago that would have been average in price, but it seems that it was one of the few shoes to not increase its price this year, and is now the lowest price shoe in the review. Since we think these are a unique and fantastic shoe, and the durability concerns seem to have been addressed, we think these shoes present a good value.

Conclusion


The Superior 2.0 by Altra is the only pair of shoes in this year's review that is zero drop. They present a remarkably different feel while running than any of the other shoes we tested. They are more sensitive than they are protective, meaning they will appeal to those with a low-profile or minimalist ethos or background. While not perfect, and not our absolute favorite shoe, we enjoy taking these out for a spin every so often.

The only zero drop shoe in our review (meaning the heel is the exact same height as the toes)  the Superior 2.0 is essentially the same shoe that we loved last year  with all of the little problems fixed. It no longer runs small and has stronger upper material to combat blow-outs.
The only zero drop shoe in our review (meaning the heel is the exact same height as the toes), the Superior 2.0 is essentially the same shoe that we loved last year, with all of the little problems fixed. It no longer runs small and has stronger upper material to combat blow-outs.

Other Versions and Accessories

  • Women's Superior 2.0 - $110 — women's version of the same shoe
  • Stoneguard Insert - $14.95 — replacement removable rock protection
  • Stability Wedge - $20 — removable insert designed to help support flat feet or over-pronators
  • Trail Gaiters - $19.99 — Altra specific trail gaiters that work with their gator trap included on their shoes.
Andy Wellman

  • Share this article:
You Might Also Like

Where to Buy?

Seller Price  Shipping Cost Visit
Amazon $109.90 Check Site

Thinking about buying some gear we've reviewed? Help OutdoorGearLab out if you do. Just click on any of the above seller links and if you make any purchase, the seller will contribute a portion of the sale to help support this site. It won't cost you anything extra, and it's a simple way to help us fund our gear reviews. Thanks!

*Most retailers free shipping offers apply only to lower 48 US states using ground/economy shipping. See retailer's website for details.


OutdoorGearLab Member Reviews


Most recent review: January 13, 2017
Summary of All Ratings

OutdoorGearLab Editors' Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (4.0)
Average Customer Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (5.0)

100% of 1 reviewers recommend it
Rating Distribution
2 Total Ratings
5 star: 50%  (1)
4 star: 50%  (1)
3 star: 0%  (0)
2 star: 0%  (0)
1 star: 0%  (0)
Sort 1 member reviews by: Most Recent | Most Helpful
Write a Review on this Gear

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Jan 13, 2017 - 02:27pm
p.db · Runner · Italy
I ran something like 120 Km with the Superior. Now, these are my favourite shoes. Simply amazing. Light, incredible traction, comfortable (ok, enough comfortable), and they're really different from any other shoe. There's a peculiarity… The SPACE. There is plenty of space inside these shoes, but they are firm also in fast changes of direction. No blisters, no problems with water, rocks, dirt, snow. They become dry really fast, not cold, not warm. The upper seems "light" but is very resistant. Nothing to say. A great, simple, fast shoe.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this product to a friend.
Help other readers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? 
Yes
 
No


Have you used the ALTRA Superior 3.0?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...

Write a Review on this Gear
 
Where's the Best Price?
Seller Price
Amazon $109.90
Compare prices at 1 sellers >

*You help support OutdoorGearLab's product testing and reviews by purchasing from our retail partners.


Follow Us


Unbiased.